I went to Chicago this past weekend to visit my brother. On night #1 he graciously took me to a gay club to play wingman and get me laid. Also he bought me about 10 dirty martinis. I saw a cute guy and decided to approach him. A few years ago I might not have been so bold with a stranger. But I’m older and I have something I never used to have: confidence. So… I took one last sip of confidence, placed the empty cup on the counter, and walked up to the cute guy. Unfortunately, however, someone else had spilled their confidence on the floor in front of the cute guy. I hit the puddle, flew 10 feet in the air and landed on the dirty floor.
But I got up. And I laughed it off and I asked him to dance. He looked me up and down, said “No.” As he walked away he elegantly circumvented the puddle of vodka tonic I had just gone swimming in. I went back to my brother, who had seen and who eyed me with pity, and I laughed about what had happened as if it were no big thing. After all, put yourself out there a lot and you might get rejected sometimes. And no use crying over spilled self, right? It’s nothing, I repeated to myself, to lose my head over.
The very next day my brother introduced me to a deliriously handsome gay guy in his building. I appreciated the gesture. I said “Hi” and shook his hand and that was the end of it.
Later on I asked my brother if he was serious about introducing me to that dude.
“What?” Zack asked. “You don’t think he’s cute?”
“Man oh man,” I said. “He’s a 10. Too cute.”
Now, I’m cute and I’ve always been partial to thinking, re: myself, that there’s just something about me. I think I’m great! But come onnnnn. A 10? What was my brother thinking? Was he so heterosexual that he couldn’t properly apply the 10-point system to men? Or was he aware that this guy was a 10 and just couldn’t rate me because I’m family.
Later on I got to thinking about the 10 Point Hotness Scale. This guy my brother introduced me to stuck in my mind. Not in any sexual way, of course. The overwhelmingly beautiful are about as sexy as the overwhelmingly ugly. But what must it be like to be a 10? To have that too-many-teeth smile. To be hot enough to get anyone.
Most people I know would call themselves 7′s, only because it’s the sole respectable rating one can give oneself. Anything higher would be laughably egotistical and anything lower would seem like a plea for a compliment.
Upon further examination I came to the conclusion that there is really no such thing as a 1, 2, 3, or 4. Anyone that ugly is probably deformed and thus exempted from cruel sexual objectification. I’ve never called anyone a 5 either. 5′s are so plain that one just doesn’t think of them numerically. Thus, most people that come under the scrutiny of the 10 point system are likely 6s, 7s, or 8s, numbers which represent the varying shades of the average, nice look of a human being.
And what is a 9, I couldn’t help but wonder? Is a 9 just a 10 with an unsightly mole or birthmark? Is a 10 always one glaring flaw away from being demoted to 9? And yes, it is a demotion. All numbers from 1 to 9 are evenly spaced. The distance between 9 and 10, however, is much more vast. It is, to some effect, unmeasurable.
Because the number 10 represents not hotness, not sexiness, not prettiness, and not cuteness. It represents perfection. That’s why it would only take one flaw to knock a 10 down to a 9. A 7 can probably have a bad breakout one month without losing a point. It’s far less delicate.
I went over to a friend’s place where we smoked 10 joints and watched 10 episodes of SATC and ate about 10 frozen waffles. I left feeling great and returned to my brother’s apartment. As I approached, though, I saw someone out front. It was him. The 10. He was outside the building smoking a cigarette. And then he went inside.
So very beautiful. So very 10. All of a sudden I felt like a 4 and I realized it. 1-9 are meaningless ratings. The only one that counts is 10. Perfection. Too many teeth. Every other rating is just relative. Relative to how close we might be standing to a 10, or how much we might foolishly let the idea of perfection get under our skin.
I thought back to Thursday night and winced. I had tried to laugh off the fact that I fell down in public and that I was rejected, but I could no longer do so. I faced the fact that while it was funny in a Charlie Chaplain kind of way, it wasn’t funny. It kind of sucked. It kind of hurt, both my ass and my feelings. I smoked one last cigarette and put away the embarassing memory and decided that I was done with the rating system.
I took the elevator up to my brother’s apartment, located on Floor 11. As I fell asleep I took comfort in the fact that I was above it all.






















